Billboard Halts Vinyl Sales Reports After Controversial 33% Decline Data Sparks Industry Dispute
Billboard has removed vinyl sales figures from its website after reporting a significant 33.3% year-over-year decline, raising questions about the accuracy of vinyl sales reporting in 2024.
The removal came after conflicting claims from key industry players:
- The Vinyl Alliance demanded corrections
- Luminate called Billboard's figures (based on their own data) 'inaccurate' and 'unauthorized'
- Independent record stores protested Luminate's new counting methodology
Billboard vinyl album sales chart
Key developments in the controversy:
- Luminate changed its vinyl sales counting methodology in 2024
- Independent retailers launched their own vinyl chart in response
- Luminate later claimed sales were up 6% after excluding indie store data
- Other organizations (RIAA, BPI, IFPI) report continued growth in vinyl shipments
The situation highlights a significant disconnect between different industry tracking methods. Billboard's parent company, Penske Media Corporation (which also owns Luminate), has not commented on the removal of vinyl sales data from Billboard's site.
Businessman checking phone with charts
Apple Music's $450 Collector Album Book
Close-up of hundred dollar bill